Is Greater Than

  • About
  • Archives
  • books
  • art + design
  • tech
  • music
  • fiction
  • food
  • Is Greater Than eBook
    • Hollywood’s Forbidden, Regressive Kingdom

      by Leland Cheuk | 30 Apr 2008

      I felt quite American this weekend while I was in Los Angeles, where it was 100 degrees and there was a wildfire in Arcadia. Instead of being concerned by the signs of hell on earth: smoke darkening the sky and the swathe of orange tracing the hill, I did what we Americans are known to do: we went to the mall to see the #1 movie in America. In this case, the #1 movie in America was The Forbidden Kingdom – the long-awaited first-time martial arts mashup of Jackie Chan and Jet Li. While Chan and Li elevate what at times might qualify as a tepid homage to classic Chinese kung-fu films (not like an homage is necessary considering a new one is made every year), the movie was generally abysmal and full of poorly developed Tolkien cliches.

      But this is not a review of The Forbidden Kingdom . This is a commentary on the unfortunate Hollywood practice of casting bad white actors at the center of a film about Asian-Americans. It’s the yellow version of the white woman inner-city teacher film cliche (Dangerous Minds , Freedom Writers ). Let’s list a few:

      - 21: Jeff Ma, the subject of the book "Burning Down the House," the true story of an MIT Blackjack Club which counted cards in Vegas on the way to winning millions, was played by Jim Sturgess

      - Balls of Fury: No one says ping-pong better than Dan Fogler, especially when he scores the beautiful Maggie Q.
      null
      - The Fast and the Furious: Tokyo Drift : no one says Tokyo better than Lucas Black

      The Forbidden Kingdom is just the latest example. The lead offender in this film is Michael Angarano is so bad in this film (in fact, all the white actors are so poorly written and such miserable actors that all of them recall Cynthia Rothrock films and make me yearn for the fine thespian line readings of Ralph Macchio . The filmmakers (Director Rob Minkoff who directed other Asian-American films like Stuart Little and Writer John Fusco, whose previous claims to fame include writing credits for Young Guns II and being friends with Jon Bon Jovi) should have just admitted that they couldn’t afford Shia Lebeouf.

      Alright, we get it Hollywood. White people can love kung-fu movies enough to mangle them too with a few too many white guys. But these stories are so transparently about Asian-Americans that there appears no other reason to include a white actor other than to appeal to white Americans. And in some ways, that’s the most offensive aspect of this trend, that Hollywood can’t conceive of a movie doing well without a white main character even though there have been plenty of examples in recent years (Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon , the Harold and Kumar movies, the Rush Hour movies, etc.). The Forbidden Kingdom is just another example of cultural laziness all around. Lazy filmmaking, lazy directing, lazy screenwriting, lazy casting. A film that’s already got two of the largest Chinese film stars going at it for the first time decides to cast a white teenager in its lead because for some reason, they didn’t feel Jackie Chan, Jet Li and a half dozen other Chinese movie stars could carry the film, even though they’ve carried a number of crappier films for the past decade. That’s the ultimate insult of The Forbidden Kingdom and the others of its kind, the willingness to wallow in old cliches cum racial stereotypes instead of taking advantage of the new diversity in Hollywood.

      For that reason, The Forbidden Kingdom is not just a bad movie, it’s a regressive one.



      Leland Cheuk is a writer whose work has appeared in publications such as The Rumpus, Spinner, 7x7.com, CellStories, Punk Planet and Mostly Fiction. Cheuk has been a MacDowell Colony Fellow and in 2007, one of Cheuk's short stories was a finalist in the national Washington Square Review fiction contest. He is working on a novel and a collection of stories.

      • Tweet

      8652 Commentshttp%3A%2F%2Fisgreaterthan.net%2F2008%2F04%2Fhollywoods-forbidden-regressive-kingdom%2FHollywood%27s+Forbidden%2C+Regressive+Kingdom2008-04-30+18%3A04%3A02Leland+Cheukhttp%3A%2F%2Fisgreaterthan.net%2F%3Fp%3D865

      • browheel

        My thoughts exactly!!

        08 May 2008 02:05 am
        Reply
        • Chanda

          You know, my wife is Chinese, and I think I cringed during The Forbidden Kingdom more than she did, hahaha.

          I am sick of things like:
          - a non-Latina actress getting the sole Latina role on season 4 of the L word (Papi) for a show set in LOS ANGELES

          - people actually thinking Angelina darkening her skin was acceptable in place of actually finding a woman of colour for the Marianne Pearl story

          etc.

          But then again, I think Hollywood responds to what American demands, and white Americans still just won’t go to the movies in the same numbers unless a white guy/gal is starring in it.

          15 May 2008 02:05 pm
          Reply

          Leave a Comment

          Posting your comment...

          Subscribe to these comments via email



          • 2007-2011

            After four years, Is Greater Than has ceased publishing. Thank you for reading and your support over the years.

            View the full archives, or browse by month, category or search below. View a full list of our contributors with links to their archive pages on the about page.

            Keep up with publisher Paul M. Davis on his personal site and his blog.

          • Search

          • Archives by Category

          • Archives by Month

            • September 2011
            • August 2011
            • July 2011
            • June 2011
            • May 2011
            • April 2011
            • March 2011
            • February 2011
            • January 2011
            • December 2010
            • November 2010
            • October 2010
            • September 2010
            • August 2010
            • July 2010
            • June 2010
            • May 2010
            • April 2010
            • March 2010
            • February 2010
            • January 2010
            • May 2009
            • April 2009
            • March 2009
            • February 2009
            • January 2009
            • December 2008
            • November 2008
            • October 2008
            • September 2008
            • August 2008
            • July 2008
            • June 2008
            • May 2008
            • April 2008
            • March 2008
            • February 2008
            • January 2008
            • December 2007
            • November 2007
            • October 2007
            • September 2007
          • COLUMNS

            • Art Can't Hurt You by Laura M. Browning
            • Moony Habitations by Leilani Clark
            • The Scheme of Spaces by Lynette D'Amico
            • A Fine Line by Cat Johnson
            • Records By Their Covers by Levi Fuller
            • Simplicities by Janina Larenas
            • Pressing Issues by Laura Pearson
            • 42 Frames by R. John Xerxes
            • Last Evenings on Earth by Michael Zapata

      Copyright 2011 Is Greater Than.

      • Paul M Davis
        • Edit My Profile
        • Dashboard
        • Log Out
      • Edit Page
      • Add New
        • Post
        • Page
      • Comments 2,101
      • Appearance
        • Widgets
        • Menus