Is Greater Than

  • About
  • Archives
  • books
  • art + design
  • tech
  • music
  • fiction
  • food
  • Is Greater Than eBook
    • Growing Up Emo

      by Paul M Davis | 11 Aug 2008

      Conor Oberst wants to grow up.

      conor Granted, the indie impresario has always been precocious. Releasing full-length albums barely into his teens, an icon for wayward teenage lovers before he could legally drink, hailed as the “New Dylan” by the age of 23–Oberst, under the guise of his Bright Eyes moniker, has always seemed accomplished far beyond his years. The record label he started with his brother in high school, Saddle Creek, is one of the largest and most influential indie labels in business today, and he has gone on to form another successful vanity label, Team Love. An indie rock magnate who happens to have been embraced by both his own generation and older rockers yearning for the deliverance of a new genius, Conor Oberst has accomplished more at the age of 28 than most punk kids will in their entire lives. He may be the U.S. Army of emo.

      But no matter how preternaturally mature Oberst might seem, his songwriting sensibility often seems perpetually prepubescent. Sure, there are plenty of the accoutrements of artistic maturity in Oberst’s work– singing with the incomparable Emmylou Harris on I’m Wide Awake, It’s Morning, flirting with orchestral arrangements on Cassadaga. But for all the artistry of those albums, there’s been a disingenuous subtext. Tellingly, despite all the plaudits for Oberst’s refined work in Bright Eyes, he seemed the most comfortable in his skin during his 2002 Desaparecidos side-project, in which he indulged his dormant punk rock chops.

      Though Bright Eyes albums such as Lifted … or I’m Wide Awake, It’s Morning stand as testaments to Oberst’s artistic development, the songwriting has always tripped upon its own preciousness. What’s precocious at 19 can be off-putting at 30, and it’s likely that no one is more aware of this than Oberst himself.

      I Want To Believe

      Gen Photo_wallpaper3 So what is an icon, already anointed a legend at the relatively young age of 28, to do? Burdened by the weight of past successes, feeling the need to make a personal, adult statement, Oberst did the unexpected: he followed the flying saucers to Tepoztl



      Paul M Davis is an Austin-based writer, editor and musician obsessed with the politics and culture of technology, social movements, music, books, art and comedy. He edits science, tech and gov 2.0 for Shareable. His personal site can be found at www.paulmdavis.com, and he blogs at 12 Pt. Plan.

      • Tweet

      11501 Commenthttp%3A%2F%2Fisgreaterthan.net%2F2008%2F08%2Fgrowing-up-emo%2FGrowing+Up+Emo2008-08-12+00%3A11%3A12Paul+M+Davishttp%3A%2F%2Fisgreaterthan.net%2F%3Fp%3D1150

      • kai smart

        Desaparecidos “Read Music, Speak Spanish” was SUCH a great album! I’m glad to see it mentioned, since it seems largely forgotten. It seems that Oberst’s voice on that album got to shed some of it’s emo tremulousness and come off as strong and defiant. Yay punk!

        27 Sep 2008 08:09 pm
        Reply

        Leave a Comment

        Posting your comment...

        Subscribe to these comments via email



        • 2007-2011

          After four years, Is Greater Than has ceased publishing. Thank you for reading and your support over the years.

          View the full archives, or browse by month, category or search below. View a full list of our contributors with links to their archive pages on the about page.

          Keep up with publisher Paul M. Davis on his personal site and his blog.

        • Search

        • Archives by Category

        • Archives by Month

          • September 2011
          • August 2011
          • July 2011
          • June 2011
          • May 2011
          • April 2011
          • March 2011
          • February 2011
          • January 2011
          • December 2010
          • November 2010
          • October 2010
          • September 2010
          • August 2010
          • July 2010
          • June 2010
          • May 2010
          • April 2010
          • March 2010
          • February 2010
          • January 2010
          • May 2009
          • April 2009
          • March 2009
          • February 2009
          • January 2009
          • December 2008
          • November 2008
          • October 2008
          • September 2008
          • August 2008
          • July 2008
          • June 2008
          • May 2008
          • April 2008
          • March 2008
          • February 2008
          • January 2008
          • December 2007
          • November 2007
          • October 2007
          • September 2007
        • COLUMNS

          • Art Can't Hurt You by Laura M. Browning
          • Moony Habitations by Leilani Clark
          • The Scheme of Spaces by Lynette D'Amico
          • A Fine Line by Cat Johnson
          • Records By Their Covers by Levi Fuller
          • Simplicities by Janina Larenas
          • Pressing Issues by Laura Pearson
          • 42 Frames by R. John Xerxes
          • Last Evenings on Earth by Michael Zapata

    Copyright 2011 Is Greater Than.

    • Paul M Davis
      • Edit My Profile
      • Dashboard
      • Log Out
    • Edit Page
    • Add New
      • Post
      • Page
    • Comments 2,101
    • Appearance
      • Widgets
      • Menus